Prevent Mosquito breeding by 1 cent copper coins: Fact or Fiction?

Received the followings from a well-intentioned colleague of mine. Quoted:

Cheap & Efficient way to stop mosquitoes.

We cannot stop mosquitoes lay eggs at any stagnant water in drains/ponds or water collected in waste pails, tanks, tins, used tyres etc. etc. Of course if you have fish inside the tanks/containers then there should be no problem.

Do you know that there is a very simple and very economical way to destroy the mosquitoes' eggs and not let them hatch into larvae. Very very simple, just put in few 1 cent copper coins into the tanks/containers then it will solve all your problems.

Because in accordance to Japanese Research Scientists, they found the mosquitoes eggs will be destroyed by a kind of mineral discharge from the copper. DON'T BELIEVE, Try it by yourself and even the small snails also will not visit the containers (with copper coins) collected with stagnant water. Your will observe the water collected in the containers will be very clean and clear.

Please Share with friends
I can't wait to try this in the summer!

The idea of being able to stop mosquito breeding by a simple method of putting in a few 1 cent copper coins piqued my interest. How come our National Environment Agency or NEA never suggested it? Unbelievable.

But wait a minute, if the preventive solution suggested above is feasible, surely NEA has done its part to encourage us to throw away those precious coins?!

That's one of the reasons I conclude that the versatile use of copper coins to prevent mosquito breeding is merely a work of fiction. (The other reason being the email quoted the unnamed Japanese Research Scientists. If it's indeed a fact, I'd have thought that the scientists would insist to be properly credited.)

Anyway, I'm still curious about the outrageous possibility of the misuse of copper coins to discourage mosquito breeding & thus, I did a quick search on the Net.

Here are the findings, the quite related articles on the subject:

1. Dated August 8, 1999:

They are brazen biters, efficient disease carriers, and hunt by day, not just at night. Stealthy and resilient, they have thwarted most scientific efforts at control and eradication.

They will try to eat you alive.

But these mosquitoes are not your garden-variety bloodsuckers. This new pest plaguing parts of the Washington region is called the Asian Tiger, and it is wreaking havoc on bare skin from Baltimore to Virginia Beach.

It is especially prevalent in inner-Beltway communities in Prince George’s County, where it has found one favorite habitat in abundance – old tires. But researchers caution they are sure that Asian Tigers are all over the metropolitan area.

How bad a bug is it? It’s so tough that this summer’s drought, which has curbed other mosquito populations, has done nothing to tame it. Instead, “they’re spreading and worsening,” said Jeannine M. Dorothy, an entomologist in the Maryland Department of Agriculture’s Mosquito Control division. “There’s really no way we can control it.”

And that’s a problem because the Asian Tiger poses a potential health threat. In laboratory settings, it has been found to be a successful disease bearer, or “vector,” able to transmit maladies affecting humans such as encephalitis, Dengue fever and yellow fever, as well as dog heartworm. Outside the laboratory, there have been no reported fatalities connected to the Asian Tiger.

“We keep watching it. We monitor it,” said Duane J. Gubler, director of vector-borne infectious diseases at the Centers for Disease Control in Fort Collins, Colo. “So far, there is no evidence that it is involved in human disease transmission.”

The Asian Tiger defies most mosquito stereotypes. It will breed in anything that holds water, even the tiniest amounts, such as flowerpots, tires, old soda cans and clogged rain gutters. It bites more often than standard-issue mosquitoes do. It has nothing against sunshine.

Researchers in New Orleans tried for almost a decade to breed a cannibal mosquito to try to check the Asian Tiger population. They were not successful. Other experts around the country also are studying the mosquito’s habits and trying to find ways of controlling it.

And to make matters worse, the Asian Tiger is out-competing the area’s native mosquito, which is a much less aggressive pest.

“They’re tearing us up. And we just basically gonna keep getting ate alive,” said Quayshawn Briscoe, 20, a resident of Fairmount Heights, one area of inner-Beltway Prince George’s that has a dense population of Asian Tigers.

So named because of white stripes on its legs and thorax, the Asian Tiger is believed to have arrived in Houston around 1985 via a shipment of tire castings from Japan. They quickly swept up the coast of the southeastern United States, transported mostly in scrap tires. Asian Tigers were found around a tire recycling plant in Baltimore in the late 1980s and showed up around the same time in Prince George’s.

Scientists describe Asian Tigers as skittish, making them hard to kill by the traditional method of death by big slap.

“There are some mosquitoes that will just sit on you, but the Asian Tiger is hard to kill because it’s very flighty,” said Stephen Sackett, field operation supervisor for the New Orleans Mosquito Control Board, which has been researching the insect for more than a decade. “The Asian Tiger will come in quick, bite and fly off.”

Insect repellent creams and sprays for the body do work, Dorothy said, but there is little else anyone can do.

“Mosquito control programs cannot adequately control this species because of its habits,” Dorothy said. “All we can do is inform the public. You’ll never get rid of them, but you can cut the numbers.”

How? By getting rid of standing water, however little, anywhere.

Dorothy and her small staff spend a lot of time posting in business windows signs that warn “The Tiger’s In Town!” The poster has a menacing-looking tiger head in the middle and gives tips about how to keep mosquitoes from breeding around the home: “Get rid of unnecessary containers.” “Change birdbath and wading pool water once a week.” “Keep ornamental pools stocked with minnows.” “Keep shrubs and grass well-trimmed.”

While traditional mosquito-control efforts target swamps, ponds and large bodies of stagnant water and most likely include nighttime neighborhood spraying (because most mosquitoes come out at dusk), “There’s no way to go around treating every flowerpot, birdbath and kiddie pool for the Asian Tiger,” said Kim Largen, the gypsy moth and mosquito control branch chief in Prince William County.

Largen said the mosquitoes were first noticed in Prince William in 1997.

“Now, pretty much anywhere we look we’re finding them,” she said.

Dorothy is investigating the unproven idea that copper might kill Asian Tiger larvae. She said cemetery workers in Louisiana noticed that bronze vases in which families leave flowers to honor the dead don’t incubate mosquitoes eggs the way ceramic and cement vases do.

To test the hypothesis that copper leaching into the water kills the Asian Tigers, Dorothy has set up little experiments in Cheverly, Bladensburg and other small Prince George’s towns. Her control tires have stagnant water in them; others hold copper tubing, old pennies and water.

“I hope it works,” she said. “If it does, we will be able to say, ‘You can control Asian Tigers and it only costs pennies a year.’. . . But for now when people call and ask me, ‘How do you get rid of them?‘ I have to say I wish I knew.”

From Washington Post, "Asian Tiger Mosquito Spreads Trouble".

2. Not dated, though:

The District Health Department Vector-Borne Diseases Program staff are finding mosquitoes breeding in many ponds in the area. Our staff usually treat the ponds initially with one of several products that kill mosquito larvae. These products are effective for about one month in suppressing larval mosquitoes. If conditions are right, the staff may also recommend planting the pond with mosquitofish (Gambusia affinis), which are avid consumers of mosquito larvae. Ponds which are not appropriate for mosquito fish require some other type of continued treatment to prevent breeding mosquitoes.

Our staff request that homeowners take responsibility for continuing mosquito prevention in their own ponds. Homeowners can take several steps to reduce the possibility of breeding mosquitoes. These include:

* Remove overhanging plants from the edge of the pond. These provide protection for breeding mosquitoes.
* Remove algae from the pond by raking or use of copper sulfate. Mosquito larvae thrive in algae.
* Line the edge of the pond with rock. This will inhibit plant growth.
* Install a small fountain or aerator. The movement of the water interferes with egg-laying by female mosquitoes. An aerator will also suppress mosquitoes by improving general water quality.
* Try using mosquito donuts for larval control. This is a product similar to one used by our staff for larval abatement. The donuts may be bought at hardware, nursery, and ornamental pond stores in the area.

Our staff are available to answer questions and provide consulting to assist you in finding long-term solutions to prevent mosquitoes from breeding in your ornamental or stock pond. Please call us at 785-4599 to inquire about this service.

From Washoe Channel, "Mosquito Prevention for Ornamental Ponds".


Post a Comment

Blog Archive